Low Hanging Fruit ✡️π»✡️π»✡️π»
The Fog of War: In summary, so far around 80 of the 240 hostages believed to have been seized by Hamas on October 7 have been released, with one more now revealed to have died in Hamas custody. Of the 80, 61 are Israelis or dual citizens. All but the one Russian/Israeli dual citizen are women or children. The remaining released hostages are foreign workers, mostly from Thailand. In exchange Israel has freed 180 Palestinian prisoners and has allowed truckloads of supplies to pass into Gaza. To make the release happen both sides have also been participating in a ceasefire, which Hamas has broken three times. US, Qatari and Egyptian officials, together with Israel and Hamas are working to extend the ceasefire pause in an attempt to get more of the hostages released. Those remaining hostages are believed to include approximately 100 Israeli citizens, the rest soldiers, though in Israel given that so much of the population participates in the military it’s not clear who Hamas considers a civilian and who they consider a soldier. Both the soldier and citizen groups are thought to include US/Israeli dual citizens. In a sane world agreeing to release women, children and the elderly should be easy, like picking low hanging fruit, but nothing is easy here as Hamas seized them in the first place and now claims that they’re not sure where some of them, including the youngest child, are being held saying some are with other terrorist groups. Count me as one who doubts that Hamas leadership doesn’t know where those hostages are though it is possible that the other groups, like Islamic Jihad, might not be cooperating fully with Hamas. Hardly surprising given that kidnappers, who seize and hold toddlers, murder, rape and dismember bodies aren’t the “best” people. To the extent that it ever happens, the release of the Israeli soldiers, or those that Hamas and the other groups believe are soldiers is likely to take much longer and require a much higher “exchange ratio,” a horrible term to use in reference to people of any nationality but an apt one given the dire circumstances.
What’s Next: Over the next few days, absent a real ceasefire agreement it’s likely that the pause in fighting will give way to bombing, missiles and the like as Israel continues to try to eradicate Hamas and Hamas fights to remain in control, embedding in hospitals, schools, mosques, and other civilian areas, which will then lead to more civilian deaths. Both Thomas Friedman and Bret Stephens have pieces in today’s NY Times which address Israel and Gaza, both are worth a read in their entirety. Friedman’s view is that looking at the war as simply between Palestinians in Gaza and Israel is simplistic, that the better way to think about what’s happening in Gaza is that “there are really three wars going on a war between Israelis and the Palestinians exacerbated by a terrorist group, a war between Israeli and Palestinian societies over the future, and a war between Iran and its proxies and America and its allies.” Friedman says that we should all “want Hamas defeated” and “as many Gazan civilians as possible spared.” In his view, progress towards peace is then made when Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and what Friedman calls his “extremist” crowd are “booted;” all the hostages are returned; Iran is deterred; and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank is “reinvigorated in partnership with moderate Arab states.” The three-war part is obvious, the replacement of Bibi is more than likely but the rest aspirational, not surprising because Friedman is an aspirational guy. In his piece, the more conservative Brett Stephens explains how the “from the river to the sea” mantra that is all the rage, including among some “progressives” who should but maybe are too ignorant to get or don’t care that it is a call for the annihilation of Israel and that in addition to embracing the “zero-sum politics of Palestinian resistance,” it encourages the “zero-sum policies of hard-core Israeli settlers and their supporters while abandoning the Palestinian people to their worst leaders.” Stephens’ position is that “the world, including Israel, has a common interest in an eventual Palestinian state that cares more about “building itself up than tearing its neighbors down” but that the “loudest professed champions of the Palestinian cause have advocated the precise opposite.” He calls that “a recipe for smug self-satisfaction, but it’s also how to kill a Palestinian state.”
The X Factor: Elon Musk flew to Israel to put in some face time with Bibi and to visit the sites of the Hamas massacre. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that Musk’s visit has more to do with X’s advertising revenues circling the drain than a genuine regret for his amplification on X (formerly Twitter) of anti-Semitic and white supremacist messages. As to Bibi, he’s being criticized for spending time with Musk but what could he do? Musk for all his many failings controls 50% of the satellites in orbit today. He’s a player on the world stage who uses his Starlink satellites to intervene in wars, not just in Gaza but also in Ukraine, in ways that suit his whims. He’s a loose cannon, but one that no leader, especially one involved in an existential war, can afford to ignore. Also, absurd, though not as dangerous George of many names Santos is still in Congress, but his days may be numbered. A vote on expelling him is expected to take place tomorrow. Though it’s still not clear if the votes to kick Santos to the curb are really there, it sounds like Speaker Mike Johnson wants him out and during the course of a few conversations has suggested that it would be a good thing for him to step down gracefully. Santos, who no one expects to do anything gracefully, has a scheduled a press conference for tomorrow. Maybe he’ll resign, maybe he’ll read a list of all those crimes he’s accused his colleagues of committing. Tune in for details. If Santos resigns or is expelled, NY law requires that Governor Hochul schedule a special election in ten days to be held within 70 to 80 days. Special election candidates are selected by local party leaders so though lots of people have indicated an interest in running for the Santos seat, there won’t be a primary for the special election candidate, just for the 2024 general election. On the subject of 2024, yesterday Nikki Haley received an endorsement from the powerful right wing Koch Brothers network. That’s great for her and provides her with lots of resources, financial and on the ground but mostly it just launches her into the second position over DeSantis. Trump remains the likely Republican candidate, warts, and all. Apparently one of those warts, was a serious loss of appetite after he lost the 2020 election. At least that’s what Liz Cheney says that former Speaker McCarthy used as his excuse for running down to Mar a Lago after the January 6th insurrection. Apparently “my Kev” had to spoon feed mashed burgers and ketchup to the Mango Maniac because he was so upset about losing the election that he claims he didn’t lose.
that he wasn’t eating.